Rooftop tents (RTTs) have taken the car camping and overlanding world by storm, offering adventurers a quick, comfortable, and elevated sleeping solution. But one of the most common questions for first-time buyers is: Should I go with a softshell or a hardshell rooftop tent?
The answer depends on your camping style, vehicle, storage space, and budget. In this guide, we’ll compare softshell vs. hardshell rooftop tents in detail, highlight the pros and cons of each, and recommend some of the best models available in 2025.
Table of Contents
- What Are Rooftop Tents?
- What Is a Softshell Rooftop Tent?
- What Is a Hardshell Rooftop Tent?
- Softshell vs. Hardshell: Head-to-Head Comparison
- Setup Time
- Durability & Weather Resistance
- Comfort & Space
- Aerodynamics & Fuel Efficiency
- Weight & Load Considerations
- Price
- Best Softshell Rooftop Tents in 2025
- Best Hardshell Rooftop Tents in 2025
- Which Rooftop Tent Is Right for You?
- Final Thoughts
What Are Rooftop Tents?
Rooftop tents are portable sleeping setups mounted on the roof rack of your car, SUV, or truck. Unlike traditional ground tents, they keep you off the ground, away from dirt, moisture, and wildlife. Most RTTs include a built-in mattress and can be deployed quickly, making them ideal for road trips, weekend getaways, or full-time overlanding.
What Is a Softshell Rooftop Tent?
A softshell rooftop tent is constructed with heavy-duty fabric (usually canvas or polyester) stretched over a fold-out frame. When packed up, it looks like a rugged fabric box. To set it up, you unfold it outward, which often doubles the footprint of your roof rack.
Pros of Softshell RTTs:
- Typically more affordable than hardshell tents
- Can accommodate more sleepers (great for families)
- More configurable interior space
- Lighter than many hardshell models
Cons:
- Longer setup/takedown time
- Less aerodynamic when closed
- More prone to wind flapping and noise
What Is a Hardshell Rooftop Tent?
A hardshell rooftop tent features a solid, often fiberglass or aluminum outer shell that opens either vertically (clam-shell style) or in a pop-up configuration. These tents are typically more aerodynamic and offer quicker deployment.
Pros of Hardshell RTTs:
- Fastest setup — some in under 60 seconds
- More durable against weather and road wear
- Often more aerodynamic, reducing drag
- Sleek, low-profile design
Cons:
- More expensive upfront
- Heavier, requiring a robust rack system
- Less room for multiple sleepers
Softshell vs. Hardshell: Head-to-Head Comparison
Setup Time
- Hardshell: Often under 60 seconds with gas-assisted struts or simple latches.
- Softshell: Typically 5–10 minutes, depending on model and weather conditions.
Winner: Hardshell
Durability & Weather Resistance
- Hardshell models shine in rain, snow, and wind. They also tend to last longer.
- Softshell tents can be weatherproof but may require extra care in harsh conditions.
Winner: Hardshell
Comfort & Space
- Softshell tents usually have a larger footprint, which can accommodate more people and gear.
- Hardshell tents are cozier but have more solid insulation and sometimes thicker mattresses.
Winner: Tie (depends on priorities: space vs. insulation)
Aerodynamics & Fuel Efficiency
- Hardshell tents are lower profile and reduce wind drag.
- Softshell tents are bulkier when closed, which can reduce MPG.
Winner: Hardshell
Weight & Load Considerations
- Softshell tents are generally lighter and easier to mount.
- Hardshell tents require stronger crossbars and lifting assistance.
Winner: Softshell
Price
- Softshell tents typically range from $900–$2,500
- Hardshell tents typically range from $2,500–$5,000
Winner: Softshell
Best Softshell Rooftop Tents in 2025
1. Smittybilt Overlander Tent
- Price: ~$1,199
- Sleeps: 2–3 people
- Weight: 117 lbs
- Why it’s great: Budget-friendly, durable, includes annex option
2. Tuff Stuff Alpha II
- Price: ~$2,395
- Sleeps: 2–3 people
- Weight: 141 lbs
- Why it’s great: Durable rip-stop material, good for off-road use
3. Roofnest Meadowlark
- Price: ~$1,595
- Sleeps: 2 people
- Weight: 90 lbs
- Why it’s great: Lightweight and compact for smaller vehicles
Best Hardshell Rooftop Tents in 2025
1. iKamper Skycamp 3.0
- Price: ~$4,199
- Sleeps: 3–4 people
- Weight: 165 lbs
- Why it’s great: Ultra-fast setup, high build quality, large interior
2. Roofnest Falcon Pro
- Price: ~$3,695
- Sleeps: 2–3 people
- Weight: 180 lbs
- Why it’s great: Slim profile, rugged design, includes roof rack capability
3. Thule Basin Wedge
- Price: ~$3,000
- Sleeps: 2 people
- Weight: 155 lbs
- Why it’s great: Vertical opening, integrated roof rack, great brand support
Which Rooftop Tent Is Right for You?
Here’s a quick cheat sheet to help you decide:
| Question | If Yes, Choose… |
|---|---|
| Are you on a tight budget? | Softshell |
| Need space for 3–4 people? | Softshell |
| Want fast setup/takedown? | Hardshell |
| Plan to camp in extreme weather? | Hardshell |
| Drive a small car with low roof weight limit? | Softshell |
| Want maximum fuel efficiency on road trips? | Hardshell |
Ultimately, the best rooftop tent is the one that fits your lifestyle, vehicle, and travel goals.
Final Thoughts
Whether you’re chasing sunsets through national parks or weekend getaways to remote trailheads, rooftop tents offer unmatched convenience and comfort. Softshell tents are fantastic for families and budget-conscious campers who want space and flexibility. Hardshell tents, on the other hand, deliver durability, sleek design, and lightning-fast setup.
Whichever route you choose, be sure to check your vehicle’s roof weight limits, install a compatible rack system, and—most importantly—get out there and enjoy the adventure.
Happy camping!
